Goolwa/Port Elliot FC Premierships - 2
- 2001 Junior Colt Grand Finalists - Goolwa/Port Elliot 5-2-32 Lt McLaren 5-8-38
- 2004 Senior Colt Grand Finalists - Goolwa/Port Elliot 6-9-45 Lt McLaren 11-6-72
- 2009 Junior Colt Grand Finalists - Goolwa/Port Elliot 5-6-36 Lt Willunga 5-7-37
- 2012 Senior Colt Premiers - Goolwa/Port Elliot 4-7-31 def Willunga 4-6-30
- 2020 Junior Colt Premiers- Goolwa/Port Elliot 10-8-66 def Willunga 4-5-29
Goolwa FC - 12 (6 A-grade, 2 Reserves, 4 Senior Colts)
- 1925 A-grade
- 1932 A-grade
- 1953 A-grade
- 1967 Senior Colts
- 1970 Senior Colts
- 1971 Senior Colts
- 1975 A-grade
- 1976 A-grade
- 1977 A-grade
- 1978 Reserves
- 1981 Reserves
- 1996 Senior Colts
Port Elliot FC - 15 (11 A-grade, 4 Reserves)
- 1927 A-grade
- 1929 A-grade
- 1931 A-grade
- 1932 A-grade
- 1933 A-grade
- 1935 A-grade
- 1936 A-grade
- 1937 A-grade
- 1938 A-grade
- 1939 A-grade
- 1960 Reserves
- 1961 Reserves
- 1962 Reserves
- 1967 Reserves
- 1973 A-grade
