(Reserves team first fielded in 1955)
(Reserves Best & Fairest became John O'Dwyer Memorial Cup in 2012)
| 2019 |
TYLER McNAMARA |
| 2018 |
JEREMEY BREWER |
| 2017 |
MITCHELL BENNETT |
| 2016 |
JEREMEY BREWER |
| 2015 |
LACHLAN BEGG |
| 2014 |
JEREMEY BREWER |
| 2013 |
JEREMEY BREWER |
| 2012 |
GREG CHAMBERS |
| 2011 |
ROB ROJEWSKI |
| 2010 |
NICK EDWARDS |
| 2009 |
DION GRIEVE |
| 2008 |
ALEX HAND |
| 2007 |
BRAD EAD |
| 2006 |
BEN MILSOM |
| 2005 |
BEN MILSOM |
| 2004 |
BRAD GARGUILIO |
| 2003 |
MURRAY COLLLINS |
| 2002 |
STEVE CAMPBELL |
| 2001 |
WES WHITE |
| 2000 |
MICK O'SHEA |
| 1999 |
I BAKER |
| 1998 |
TY SIERMANS/CAM ROGISTER |
| 1997 |
W PALFREY |
| 1996 |
TERRY RULE |
| 1995 |
ALAN KENNEDY |
| 1994 |
WILLIAM WHATLEY |
| 1993 |
SHANE TUOHEY |
| 1992 |
WILLIAM WHATLEY |
| 1991 |
TERRY TUOHEY |
| 1990 |
STEPHEN CONROY |
| 1989 |
WILLIAM WHATLEY |
| 1988 |
BARNEY TUOHEY |
| 1987 |
DENIS RONEY |
| 1986 |
BARNEY TUOHEY |
| 1985 |
BARNEY TUOHEY |
| 1984 |
BRYAN HICKSON |
| 1983 |
BRYAN HICKSON |
| 1982 |
LLOYD KENNEDY |
| 1981 |
IAN COWAN |
| 1980 |
LLOYD KENNEDY |
| 1979 |
SHANE FRAWLEY |
| 1978 |
KELVIN PITSON |
| 1977 |
PETER NIHILL |
| 1976 |
GERARD CARBOON |
| 1975 |
JOHN NIHILL |
| 1974 |
J RONEY |
| 1973 |
LAURIE BENNETT |
| 1972 |
TONY FRAWLEY |
| 1971 |
DAMIEN KENNEDY |
| 1970 |
DAN TUOHEY |
| 1969 |
VIN KEOGH |
| 1968 |
LAURIE COLLINS |
| 1967 |
NOEL ROULSTON |
| 1966 |
B DOHERTY |
| 1965 |
GARY HARROP |
| 1964 |
|
| 1963 |
N RYAN |
| 1962 |
J CONROY |
| 1961 |
|
| 1960 |
|
| 1959 |
|
| 1958 |
|
| 1957 |
J NIELSON |
| 1956 |
|
| 1955 |
|
